This is a unique novel. It's fantasy, yes, but fantasy which feels very close to home. The world and characters are all fictional, but the characters are all human. You'll not find talking animals or mythical beasts in this novel, but that is not the most important distinction that sets it apart from any other fantasy I've read.Any author writing fantasy has to decide what to do about the supernatural, and I've read books that take different approaches. Some are heavily allegorical, with elements that mirror God, Jesus, or the creation, but are really just symbolic. Some create a deity with the attributes of God but a different story of the world than that of Scripture. Some just ignore the supernatural, or else have some vague, undefined something.
For me as a Christian, none of these approaches fully ring true. Reading about characters who do what is right because they think it's right, or because it's what is expected of them, or because it satisfies them, or even because it is whatever is desired by whatever supernatural power the author has chosen to use, is simply not the same as reading about characters who are committed to following the commands of God as conveyed in His revealed Word, while recognizing their own unworthiness and rejoicing in the redemption from sin that comes only through the sacrifice of Jesus, the Son of God-- which is exactly what Ari Heinze displays in Bright Against the Storm.
And it works. It works beautifully! I have always loved medieval fantasy, with knights and adventures and swordfights and deeds of bravery and honor and great sacrifice, but in recent times as I have become interested in writing myself, I have had to consider this aspect of fantasy. This is the approach I want to take, and it was so inspiring to see this idea carried out. The religion in this story is not something man-made; it is the true, real, and only satisfying faith in the God of the Bible, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, who sent His only Son Jesus to earth to redeem His people from their sins. The trappings of today's church are gone, and the Bible goes by a different name, but it's there all the same. We see characters who have devoted their lives to this faith, who still struggle with temptation and weakness, but are yet victorious as Christ works in them. We see them forced by circumstances to depend on God through prayer. We see them showing mercy and love in God's name. We also see the ultimate hopelessness of those who do not believe, who believe that this life is all there is.
Aside from the theological aspects of this book, it's just a really great story. The characters are well-developed. There is action, suspense, mystery, and romance.
Speaking of romance-- there are some beautifully portrayed marriages in this book. This also brings me to one aspect I didn't agree with: There is an engaged couple in which the woman is a believer and the man is not. We see her heartache at her beloved's blindness, but the rightness of her choosing to marry an unbeliever is never questioned. The other aspect I didn't agree with was a circumstance in which there are some people that are testing a character in order to find out if he is true and faithful. To that end, they purposefully place temptation in his path. I found the justification for this questionable.
Despite the fact that this story takes place on the eve of war and that the characters experience pain, danger, doubt, and suffering, I can only think of this book as a celebration: a celebration of justice, loyalty, faithfulness, beauty, courage, selflessness, and love-- both God's love and the love that because of Him is shown forth among His people.
Now I just have to be patient and wait for books two through four...
Learn more or buy the book here: http://www.hopewriter.com/Karolan.html
Anna, thanks for the review! It is nice to have some suggestions for good reads. :) I look forward to seeing you on Sunday.
ReplyDelete~Janiece
You're welcome! See you Sunday!
ReplyDelete~Anna
I enjoyed reading your review, Anna! I am currently reading my way through Ari's book myself and finding the quality of his writing quite delightful. He is truly a gifted author. I appreciated you explaining the differences between the various types of fantasies out there...that is one subject I've never really understood. I also agree with you on the point that Naomi should not have pledged her life to a non-believer...but I have this feeling that Jonathan will become a believer before the series is over!
ReplyDeleteThank you! I agree with you about Jonathan's becoming a believer before the series is over. I think this book has settled among my top favorites!
ReplyDelete~Anna
Thank you for writing this review. My son (15) loves to read. After reading your review I will get this book for him. I'm very picky about what I let him read. Thanks for helping make the decision easy.
ReplyDeleteWanda
I just finished reading "Bright Against the Storm" and really loved it:-)
ReplyDeleteYou drew me in to the character's lives and made me fall in love with them. You stimulated my imagination with your descriptions of the landscape but gave me dialogue which I require to hold my interest in a story. I am ready for Book #2...Carole
Carole--
ReplyDeleteThis is not Ari Heinze's site, so if you'd like to share your feedback with him, I would suggest that you e-mail him. I believe his address was in the book.
I, like you, am looking forward to the rest of the series!
~Anna
Would you consider this book to be suitable reading for a 13-year-old girl who loves to read? What do you think is the appropriate age level for this book?
ReplyDeleteThank you for your comments.
Becky,
ReplyDeleteI would be inclined to think that thirteen is a bit young. I would probably recommend the book for ages 15 and up. There is a scene where one of the main characters is confronted with a tempation of a sexual nature. While it is tastefully done, I would encourage parents to evaluate whether or not their child is ready for that type of material.
~Anna
The characters do struggle with having tried to tempt another character and express sorrow and seek forgiveness for that. As far as being unequally yoked goes, it happens all to often, i.e. a Christian woman is trying to "change" a guy and be a witness to him. I agree that I wish her father had expressed some Godly counsel to her abut it, but haven't seen any yet and I am 70% thru the book. I guess that things in Karolan are broken and messy and people, even believers, don't always conform to scriptural standards. Interesting it would be if there were some consequences later of this and I guess I will happily read on.
ReplyDelete